The Center of the California Enterprise Zone Information Universe

“Scoring” The Enterprise Zone Program

There is an educational item in Capitol Weekly by John Howard examining the issue of how various things are “scored” for their value in the State budget. Very often items are deemed to be worth one thing for the purpose of the budget, but turn out to be worth a very different amount in reality:

The use of funny money is not new. Earlier administrations did the same thing.

One memorable example: The sale of Agnews State Hospital in the Silicon Valley, scored in successive budgets as a revenue producer, finally was sold. “It was a classic. They must have scored Agnews seven times before it sold, and each time it went up and got more valuable,” said one fiscal expert familiar with the issue. The 81-plus acres finally sold for $51 million in the mid-1990s.

The administration several months ago sought to sell off a piece of the State Compensation Insurance Fund to capture $1 billion, a move that fiscal analysts in and out of government said was poorly thought out and unworkable even before the ink was dry on the proposal. Workable or not, the sale can’t go proceed now because of litigation.

“We were ready to go forward and have been prepared to go forward, but there is a lawsuit challenging the ability of the state to do so,” Palmer noted.

The governor, several times, inflated the level of tribal gaming revenues on the General Fund by potentially hundreds of millions of dollars. He fruitlessly sought to privatize the Ed Fund – the repository of student-loan payments – and wildly overestimated its value at $1 billion.

He sought to privatize the lottery, unsuccessfully, despite expert advice that the move was not feasible, and earlier in his governorship he factored $450 million in revenue into his spending proposal based on the state’s projected share of punitive damage award dollars – money that never arrived. An LAO assessment at the time estimated the state’s potential take at $60 million – less than a one-seventh the figure predicted by Schwarzenegger. But even that estimate was wildly optimistic.

He sought to sell and then lease back state office buildings, and scored the savings at $300 million; the plan died, but is in the works again this year, probably closer to $200 million In his latest budget, he wants to save perhaps $200 million by releasing imprisoned, undocumented immigrants because the federal government isn’t paying fore their incarceration.

He had counted on $100 million a year from a hotly contested offshore oil-drilling project that has been turned down by the State Lands Commission, thrice opposed by his own choice for lieutenant governor, Sen. Abel Maldonado, R-Santa Maria, and disliked in the Legislature. The administration would like to see the project reconsidered and approved by the State Lands Commission, or given the go-ahead in a bill approved by the Legislature. Last year, legislation to do that made it through one house.

One plan, to receive upfront a share of tobacco settlement money due to California did work out. It remains an example of successful, creative financing, worth more than $1 billion.
“Some of these revenue proposals have worked out but lots of them haven’t, based on either being too optimistic or too complicated for the state to ultimately pull them off,” said Michael Cohen, deputy legislative analyst.

When evaluate recommendations to eliminate the Enterprise Zone program and use those funds for something else, it is important to keep in mind that there is no bank account with funds sitting in it for the EZ program. Since the “cost” of the program is a function of how much less in taxes profitable companies will be paying, it should be very difficult to get an accurate “score” for the budget, especially in a down economy. If the loss of an Enterprise Zone results in the loss of businesses and jobs, it’s likely to cost the budget much more revenue than it gains.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow maxshenker on Twitter

Receive By Email

Enter your email address and receive the EZ Policy Blog by email.